Branch Manager - Midwest

Old Republic Surety Company

$140K — $220K *
Finance & Insurance
5 - 7 years of experience
Job Overview by Ladders

Qualifications

  • 5+ years of experience in surety underwriting, marketing, and production (7+ years preferred)
  • Demonstrated leadership experience in mentoring underwriting professionals
  • Strong knowledge of contract surety and fidelity underwriting principles
  • Proven success in agency relationship management and business development
  • Excellent communication, analytical, and decision-making skills

Responsibilities

  • Lead, coach, and develop a team of Surety Contract Underwriters
  • Set and achieve profit, production, and underwriting quality goals
  • Make key underwriting decisions to strengthen the surety portfolio
  • Travel to meet with agency partners and pursue new business
  • Represent the company at industry events
  • Prepare budgets and monitor branch financial performance
  • Utilize CRM software for tracking agency activity and production data
  • Recruit and cultivate a strong branch culture aligned with company values

Benefits

  • Annual Performance Recognition Plan bonus eligibility
  • Comprehensive medical, dental, and vision insurance
  • Life, disability, and supplemental insurance options
  • 401(k) retirement plan with company match
  • Profit-sharing plan and Roth 401(k) options
  • 529 education savings plan
  • Employee referral bonus program
Full Job Description
Description

Branch Manager

Location: Midwest Region (Wisconsin, Iowa, Nebraska and South Dakota)

Work Arrangement: Hybrid near our office, with the option to work fully remotely if you are not located within commuting distance.

Old Republic Surety is seeking an experienced Branch Manager to lead and grow our Midwest-based surety operation. This is a hands-on leadership role for a proven surety professional who excels in underwriting, business development, and team leadership.
Duties That Make an Impact

As a Branch Manager, you will play a pivotal role in shaping both business performance and team success. Key responsibilities include:
  • Leading, coaching, and developing a team of Surety Contract Underwriters and future Associate Underwriters
  • Setting and achieving profit, production, and underwriting quality goals
  • Making key underwriting decisions that strengthen and grow the surety portfolio
  • Traveling throughout the territory to meet with agency partners, pursue new business, and strengthen relationships
  • Representing Old Republic at industry and trade events
  • Preparing budgets, managing expenses, and monitoring branch financial performance
  • Utilizing CRM software to track agency activity, marketing initiatives, and production data
  • Recruiting, training, and developing talent while cultivating a strong branch culture aligned with company values

This role offers the opportunity to directly influence strategy, team development, and long-term growth.
Experience & Qualifications

The ideal candidate will bring:
  • A minimum of five years of experience in surety underwriting, marketing, and production (seven or more years strongly preferred)
  • Demonstrated leadership experience with the ability to mentor and develop underwriting professionals
  • Strong knowledge of contract surety and fidelity underwriting principles
  • Proven success in agency relationship management and business development
  • Excellent communication, analytical, and decision-making skills
Compensation & Benefits

We offer a highly competitive compensation and benefits package, including:
  • Salary range: $140,000-$220,000, commensurate with experience
  • Eligibility for our annual Performance Recognition Plan bonus program
  • Comprehensive benefits package including:
    • Medical, dental, and vision insurance
    • Life, disability, and supplemental insurance options
  • Financial and retirement benefits:
    • 401(k) with company match
    • Profit-sharing plan
    • Roth 401(k) options
    • 529 education savings plan
  • Employee referral bonus program

Interested? Click 'apply' and follow some very simple steps to get your resume in front of the Talent Acquisition Team.

#LI-EA1

Similar Jobs

More Finance & Insurance Jobs

Find similar Branch Manager - Midwest jobs: