Senior Tax Manager

Agresta Storms and O'Leary PC

$100K — $130K *
Legal & Accounting
8 - 10 years of experience
Job Overview by Ladders

Qualifications

  • Active CPA license required
  • 10-15+ years of progressive public accounting experience
  • Exceptional technical tax knowledge
  • Proven ability to manage and develop teams
  • Strong client-facing and advisory skills
  • Solid accounting knowledge to assist staff
  • Partnership-heavy tax experience preferred

Responsibilities

  • Serve as the primary tax expert for complex issues
  • Review 450-550 tax returns annually
  • Support staff and managers with accounting questions
  • Manage and develop 1-2 Tax Managers
  • Build and maintain strong client relationships
  • Sign off on tax returns with full authority
  • Collaborate with leadership on technical matters and process improvements

Benefits

  • Clear path to partnership for high achievers
  • No requirement to bring a book of business
  • Focus on technical execution and client service
  • Trust-based culture emphasizing results over hours worked
  • Flexible work schedule and hybrid options
  • Dress for Your Day policy
  • Competitive PTO and holiday package
  • Health and dental insurance coverage
  • 401(k) match from employer
  • Performance-based bonus opportunities
  • Collaborative environment that respects work-life balance
  • Competitive compensation with partnership discussions during interviews
Full Job Description
Title: Senior Tax Manager

Location: Batesville / Greensburg / Indianapolis / Columbus, IN (All Office Locations Considered)

WORK ARRANGEMENT

This role is primarily in-office, with hybrid flexibility based on experience and performance. The firm's leadership team values a collaborative, in-person culture while recognizing that top performers benefit from the flexibility to manage their schedules around client needs and personal commitments.

KEY RESPONSIBILITIES
• Serve as the firm's primary technical tax resource, providing expert guidance on complex tax matters across a diverse client base
• Review approximately 450-550 tax returns annually; preparation is handled at more junior levels (less than 10% personal preparation work)
• Act as a sounding board for accounting-related questions from staff and managers
• Manage and develop 1-2 Tax Managers, fostering professional growth and ensuring quality standards
• Maintain strong, direct relationships with clients in a highly client-facing role requiring excellent communication and advisory skills
• Sign off on tax returns with full authority, with increasing autonomy as trust is established (or immediately for qualified candidates)
• Collaborate with firm leadership on technical matters, process improvement, and maintaining the firm's reputation for excellence

REQUIRED QUALIFICATIONS
• Active CPA license (required)
• 10-15+ years of progressive public accounting experience
• Exceptional technical tax acumen with the ability to serve as a confident, go-to resource for the firm's tax practice
• Demonstrated ability to manage teams and develop talent
• Strong client-facing skills with a track record of building trusted advisor relationships
• Accounting knowledge sufficient to serve as a resource for staff questions
• Partnership-heavy tax experience preferred; industry agnostic

PREFERRED QUALIFICATIONS
• Experience with CCH tax software environment (or demonstrated ability to learn new platforms quickly)
• Experience in a leadership or practice-area leadership capacity
• Readiness to take on increasing responsibility with a trajectory toward partnership

WHAT ASO OFFERS
• Clear and accelerated path to partnership for high performers
• No requirement to bring a book of business; ample existing client work and organic growth opportunities
• Primary focus on technical execution and client service. This is not a rainmaker role, though client relationship development is valued as the practice continues to grow
• A trust-based, output-driven culture where leadership measures results, not keystrokes. Top performers are given real autonomy, flexibility around personal commitments, and the latitude to manage their own schedules
• Hybrid work schedule with a flexible offseason schedule
• Dress for Your Day policy
• Competitive PTO package plus holidays, with additional time off negotiable outside of busy season
• Health and dental insurance
• Employer 401(k) match
• Performance-based bonus opportunity
• A collaborative, family-friendly environment that genuinely respects work-life balance without sacrificing professional standards
• Competitive compensation with partnership economics discussed during the interview process

COMPENSATION & HOURS

Compensation is commensurate with experience, qualifications, and the value the candidate brings to the practice. The firm offers a competitive base salary, performance-based bonus structure, and a clearly defined equity partnership path. Full details will be discussed during the interview process.

Expected billable hours in the range of 1,400-1,600 annually (2,300-2,400 total hours), consistent with senior leadership expectations.

Similar Jobs

More Legal & Accounting Jobs

Find similar Senior Tax Manager jobs: