New York Life Insurance Co

MANAGER, Annuity New Business Call Center

New York Life Insurance Co$73K — $104K *
Finance & Insurance
Less than 5 years of experience
Job Overview by Ladders

Qualifications

  • 3-5 years in customer service, call center, or financial services roles
  • Proven team leadership in a customer-focused environment
  • Strong organizational skills to manage multiple priorities
  • Excellent communication skills
  • Ability to analyze data and make strategic decisions
  • Strong leadership presence with a focus on team development
  • Familiarity with Microsoft Office Suite and data navigation

Responsibilities

  • Lead and develop a team of call center professionals for performance improvement
  • Manage daily operations including inbound call performance and servicing levels
  • Monitor performance metrics and execute coaching strategies
  • Set clear expectations for accountability and standards
  • Utilize data insights for decision-making and operational optimization
  • Conduct performance reviews and support career growth initiatives
  • Collaborate with cross-functional teams to enhance customer and agent experience

Benefits

  • Paid vacation and holidays
  • Medical, dental, and vision coverage
  • 401(k) match plus pension plan
  • Tuition assistance and flexible spending accounts
Full Job Description
Job Requisition ID: 94295

Location Designation: Hybrid - 6 days per month

Annuity New Business Call Center Manager

Department: Purchase Experience - Annuity New Business Location: Dallas, TX | Hybrid, onsite 1 day per week Schedule: Full-time | Monday-Friday | 7.5-hour shift between 9:30 AM - 6:00 PM CST Company: New York Life Insurance Company

Role Overview

We are seeking a dynamic and forward-thinking leader to join our team as a Call Center Manager in Dallas, leading the Annuity New Business Call Center team responsible for supporting agents with new business processing, onboarding inquiries, application requirements, and related service needs.

This role plays a critical part in ensuring operational excellence, delivering accurate and timely outcomes, and creating a consistent, positive experience for agents and clients. The manager will be responsible for coaching and developing call center professionals, monitoring performance, driving accountability, and supporting continuous improvement across the team.

The ideal candidate brings a balance of strong operational discipline, customer-centric leadership, and people leadership, with the ability to navigate complexity, influence outcomes, and lead through change. This is an opportunity to make a meaningful impact by shaping team performance, improving service delivery, and contributing to the ongoing evolution of the Purchase Experience organization.

What You'll Do
• Lead, coach, and develop a high-performing team of call center professionals, driving accountability, engagement, and continuous improvement.
• Manage daily call center operations, including inbound call performance, service levels, staffing needs, quality expectations, and timely resolution of agent inquiries.
• Own team performance by monitoring key metrics, identifying gaps, and executing targeted coaching and development strategies.
• Foster a culture of accountability by setting clear expectations and holding team members to defined goals, standards, and behaviors.
• Utilize data, reporting, call trends, and performance insights to inform decision-making and optimize operational outcomes.
• Deliver performance reviews, development planning, and career coaching to support employee growth and retention
• Partner with peers, leadership, training, quality, suitability, and operations teams to streamline workflows, mitigate risk, and enhance overall customer and agent experience.
• Ensure strict adherence to company policies, procedures, regulatory requirements, and service standards within a highly controlled environment.
• Lead and contribute to strategic initiatives, projects, and process enhancements aligned with organizational priorities.
• Support a positive onsite and hybrid team culture in the Dallas office, including a regular onsite presence of 1 day per week.

What You'll Bring

Required Skills
• 3-5 years of experience in customer service, call center, operations, or financial services environment.
• Demonstrated success leading teams in a customer-centric environment, with a focus on delivering exceptional service and driving results.
• Ability to de-escalate challenging situations and drive mutually beneficial resolutions.
• Highly organized with the ability to manage multiple priorities in a demanding environment.
• Excellent verbal, written, and active listening skills, with the ability to communicate effectively across all levels.
• Proven ability to analyze data, leverage insights, and make informed, strategic decisions.
• Strong leadership presence with the ability to inspire, influence, and develop high-performing teams.
• Strong interpersonal awareness and sound judgment, with the ability to navigate complex and sensitive situations effectively.
• Proficiency in Microsoft Office Suite (Word, Excel, PowerPoint) and comfort navigating systems and data tools.
• Ability to work from the Dallas office 1 day per week.

Preferred Skills
• Bachelor's degree or equivalent business experience.
• 2-5 years of experience in a customer service and/or call center setting, preferably within insurance, annuities, investments, or financial services.
• Knowledge of insurance and/or investment industry products, processes, and regulatory expectations.
• Proficiency with AI-enabled tools, such as ChatGPT or Microsoft Copilot, to enhance productivity, streamline workflows, and support decision-making.
• Experience using call center performance data, quality reviews, and workforce insights to improve service delivery and team outcomes.
• Experience leading through change, supporting process improvements, and building engagement in a hybrid team environment.

Training & Development

You will receive comprehensive training and ongoing leadership support, including:
• Insurance and financial products.
• New business processes, application workflows, and service expectations.
• Call center management practices, quality standards, and performance coaching routines.
• Leadership development, feedback, and continuous improvement support.

Ongoing coaching and feedback will support your growth and success in the role.

Compensation & Schedule
• Competitive base salary.
• Full-time role: Monday-Friday, with coverage aligned to business needs between 9:30 AM - 6:00 PM CST.
• Hybrid role based in Dallas, TX, with an onsite expectation of 1 day per week.

Benefits
• Paid vacation and holidays.
• Medical, dental, and vision coverage.
• 401(k) match plus pension plan.
• Tuition assistance and flexible spending accounts

Job Level: LEVELMG1

Pay Transparency

Salary Range: $73,000-$104,000

Overtime eligible: Exempt

Discretionary bonus eligible: Yes

Sales bonus eligible: No

Actual base salary will be determined based on several factors but not limited to individual's experience, skills, qualifications, and job location. Additionally, employees are eligible for an annual discretionary bonus. In addition to base salary, employees may also be eligible to participate in an incentive program.

Please note: This role requires FINRA licensed and/or FINRA Associated Person pre-hire fingerprinting.

About New York Life Insurance Co

New York Life Insurance Company is a mutual life insurance company in the United States and one of the life insurers in the world, ranking #88 on the 2014 Fortune 500 list with over $540 billion in total assets under management, and more than $19 billion in surplus and AVR. New York Life and its subsidiaries provide insurance, investment, and retirement solutions. For 175 years, the company has been helping people put their love into action. It was founded in 1845 and is headquartered in New York.

New York Life Insurance Co Careers

Join the esteemed team at New York Life Insurance Co, a leader in the insurance industry, and propel your career to new heights with unparalleled job opportunities. As one of the most respected names in life insurance, we offer a platform where professionalism meets innovation, creating an environment ripe for personal and professional growth.

Work You’ll Do

At New York Life Insurance Co, you will be part of a culture that cherishes diversity and fosters leadership. Our team is composed of skilled professionals dedicated to providing financial security and peace of mind to our clients. By joining us, you will collaborate with top-tier experts in finance and insurance, leveraging your skills to make a meaningful impact.

Explore Career Paths

Whether you are seeking an internship, a full-time position, or a leadership role, New York Life Insurance Co provides a variety of career paths to help you achieve your professional goals. Our commitment to career development is evident through extensive training programs and continuous learning opportunities that ensure our team remains at the forefront of the industry.

Innovate and Lead

Embrace the opportunity to lead projects that drive innovation within the company and the insurance industry. New York Life Insurance Co is at the intersection of tradition and innovation, where we constantly strive to develop solutions that anticipate the needs of our clients.

Be Part of a Great Team

Our team at New York Life Insurance Co is our greatest asset. We thrive on collaboration and respect each other’s contributions, creating a supportive and inclusive workplace. Here, networking and mentorship go hand in hand with day-to-day operations, providing a robust support system for career advancement.

Future-Proof Your Career

With New York Life Insurance Co, your career is future-proofed with endless opportunities for advancement. Our comprehensive benefits package supports your life both inside and outside of work, while our leadership and diversity training prepare you to take on new challenges.

Join Our Team

Search for open positions that match your skills and interests. We are hiring creative, curious, and motivated individuals who are ready to drive their careers forward. Explore our job opportunities and find out how your talents can make a difference at New York Life Insurance Co.

Stay Connected

Keep up to date with the latest industry trends, career tips, and company news through our Careers Blog. Personalize your experience by subscribing to job alert emails, tailored to your preferences, and discover the exciting and rewarding opportunities that await at New York Life Insurance Co.

Prepare for Your Interview

Ready to join us? Prepare your resume and sharpen your interview skills to become part of a company that values vision, leadership, and a commitment to excellence. At New York Life Insurance Co, we are not just offering a job; we are offering a pathway to success.

New York Life Insurance Co – A Place Where Careers Are Made

From fostering innovation to encouraging diversity, New York Life Insurance Co is where you can pursue your passions and grow your career. Join us and make a difference in the lives of our clients and communities every day.
Learn more about New York Life Insurance Co
Size
11,960 employees
Industry
Founded
1845

Similar Jobs

More Jobs at New York Life Insurance Co

More Finance & Insurance Jobs

Find similar MANAGER, Annuity New Business Call Center jobs: