First MidIllinois Bancshares, Inc

Chief Revenue Officer - Insurance

First MidIllinois Bancshares, Inc • $120K — $175K *
Finance & Insurance
8 - 10 years of experience
Job Overview by Ladders

Qualifications

  • Bachelor's degree in Business, Finance, or related field (MBA preferred).
  • 10+ years of leadership experience in insurance, banking, or a combined financial services environment.
  • Proven success in driving revenue growth within a relationship-based, referral-driven model.
  • Deep understanding of insurance products (P&C, benefits, life) and community banking operations.
  • Demonstrated ability to build and sustain cross-functional partnerships.
  • Strong leadership presence with the ability to influence both bank and agency teams.
  • Strategic mindset with hands-on execution capability.

Responsibilities

  • Develop and execute a revenue growth strategy aligned with the insurance agency and parent bank's objectives.
  • Directly manage and develop insurance team members, implementing effective sales processes.
  • Identify opportunities to expand insurance offerings within the bank's customer base.
  • Partner with executive leadership to drive integrated financial services solutions.
  • Build strong partnerships with banking teams to enhance referral pipelines.
  • Design and implement cross-sell strategies for seamless customer experience.
  • Establish processes and incentives to engage bankers in insurance referrals.
  • Lead agency sales and talent acquisition across various insurance lines.
  • Optimize a hybrid distribution model leveraging bank and agency resources.
  • Champion a relationship-first approach that aligns with community banking values.
  • Drive client retention and satisfaction through personalized service models.
  • Represent the organization in community and industry engagements to build brand awareness.

Benefits

  • Competitive health, dental & vision coverage with HSA match.
  • 401(k) with employer match and Employee Stock Purchase Plan.
  • Generous PTO, paid holidays & parental leave.
  • Tuition reimbursement & performance-based bonuses.
  • Visit our Total Rewards page to see our full list of benefits.
Full Job Description
The Chief Revenue Officer (CRO) for the First Mid Insurance Group is a strategic leader responsible for organic growth and for driving revenue growth across the insurance agency while aligning closely with the community bank's overall financial, customer, and relationship strategies. This role ensures seamless integration between banking and insurance services, maximizing cross-sell opportunities, deepening client relationships, and enhancing the overall customer experience.

The CRO leads all revenue-generating functions, including sales, bank channel partnerships, and client retention, while fostering a culture rooted in community engagement, trust, and long-term relationship management.

Responsibilities include, but are not limited to:
  • Develop and execute a revenue growth strategy aligned with both the insurance agency and parent bank's strategic objectives.
  • Directly manage and develop insurance team members, implementing sales processes to ensure a high level of success.
  • Identify opportunities to expand insurance offerings within the bank's customer base.
  • Partner with executive leadership to drive integrated financial services solutions.
  • Build strong partnerships with retail banking, commercial banking, and wealth management teams to drive referral pipelines.
  • Design and implement cross-sell strategies that embed insurance solutions into the bank's customer lifecycle.
  • Establish processes, training, and incentives to support banker engagement in insurance referrals.
  • Lead agency sales and sales talent acquisition across all lines (e.g., commercial property & casualty, personal lines, employee benefits, life).
  • Oversee producer performance, pipeline management, and sales effectiveness.
  • Optimize a hybrid distribution model leveraging both bank referrals and independent agency production.
  • Champion a relationship-first approach that aligns with community banking values.
  • Drive client retention, satisfaction, and lifetime value through personalized service models.
  • Ensure a consistent and high-quality experience across both bank and agency touchpoints.
  • Strengthen the agency's presence within local communities served by the bank.
  • Identify opportunities for growth in key markets and customer segments.
  • Represent the organization in community and industry engagements to build brand awareness.
  • Cultivate relationships with carriers, wholesalers, and strategic partners to enhance product offerings and competitiveness.
  • Evaluate acquisition opportunities and partnerships that align with growth objectives.
  • Support integration efforts for newly acquired agencies or teams.
  • Establish and track key performance metrics tied to revenue growth, cross-sell success, and client retention.
  • Provide regular reporting and insights to executive leadership and the board.
  • Drive accountability across sales and relationship teams.
  • Ensure all revenue-generating activities comply with banking and insurance regulations.
  • Partner with compliance and risk teams to maintain adherence to applicable laws and internal policies.
  • Promote ethical sales practices consistent with the bank's reputation and values.
  • Serves in a senior management role within FMIG. In this capacity may be responsible for other management responsibilities including personnel decisions, budgeting, P&L responsibility, decisions with regards to talent recruitment/termination, strategic planning, employee engagement initiatives and other high-level management projects and initiatives.


Qualifications

Education/Experience:
  • Bachelor's degree in Business, Finance, or related field (MBA preferred).
  • 10+ years of leadership experience in insurance, banking, or a combined financial services environment.
  • Proven success in driving revenue growth within a relationship-based, referral-driven model.


Skills:
  • Deep understanding of insurance products (P&C, benefits, life) and community banking operations.
  • Demonstrated ability to build and sustain cross-functional partnerships.
  • Strong leadership presence with the ability to influence both bank and agency teams.
  • Strategic mindset with hands-on execution capability.
  • High level of integrity and commitment to customer-centric service.


Total Rewards:
  • Competitive health, dental & vision coverage with HSA match
  • 401(k) with employer match + Employee Stock Purchase Plan
  • Generous PTO, paid holidays & parental leave
  • Tuition reimbursement & performance-based bonuses
  • Visit our Total Rewards page to see our full list of benefits


Pay Range: $120,500 - $175,000 per year

About First MidIllinois Bancshares, Inc

MidFirst Bank is a privately owned financial institution based in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma. It is the largest privately owned bank in the United States, with $32.1 billion in assets. Its primary markets include Oklahoma, Denver, Phoenix and Dallas, with commercial lending offices in Atlanta, Boston, Chicago, Cleveland, Houston, New York City, St. Louis, and Southern California. MidFirst Bank has banking centers in Boulder and Edwards, Colorado. Additionally, the bank operates 1st Century Bank of Los Angeles as a division of MidFirst Bank and MidFirst Business Credit of Atlanta as a subsidiary of MidFirst Bank.
Learn more about First MidIllinois Bancshares, Inc
Size
1,050 employees
Market Cap
$655.1 million
Industry
Net Income
$45.2 million
5 Year Trend
+19.4%
NASDAQ

Similar Jobs

More Jobs at First MidIllinois Bancshares, Inc

More Finance & Insurance Jobs

Find similar Chief Revenue Officer - Insurance jobs: