Nationwide Insurance

Senior Consultant, Claims Casualty - E&S/Specialty (Traditional Environmental Property Damage and Bodily Injury)

Nationwide Insurance$122K — $214K *
US-AnywhereRemote in United States
Finance & Insurance
8 - 10 years of experience
Job Overview by Ladders

Qualifications

  • 5-7 years of experience in insurance claims, particularly in specialty lines.
  • Deep expertise in environmental liability, mass toxic torts, and complex allocation methodologies.
  • Understanding of litigation strategies and risk management of high-severity claims, particularly with policies exceeding $10-50 million.
  • Proficient in negotiations and managing reserve levels per company standards.
  • Advanced degree and industry certifications (like CPCU) preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Investigate and resolve high-value E&S claims from start to finish, handling unique risks.
  • Manage reserves, ensuring compliance and recommending special reserves when necessary.
  • Develop litigation strategies while liaising with defense counsel on handling lawsuits.
  • Cultivate relationships with stakeholders including agents, brokers, and product developers to enhance claims outcomes.
  • Provide expertise in specialty lines, supporting new product development with standardized processes.
  • Act as a subject matter expert, identifying training needs for the division and delivering specialized training.
  • Offer strategic consultation to E&S Claims leadership and other business partners on severe claims issues.

Benefits

  • Medical, dental, and vision insurance.
  • Life insurance, short and long-term disability coverage.
  • Minimum of 18 days paid time off annually, plus 9 paid holidays.
  • 401(k) with company matching and pension plan contributions.
  • Business casual dress code and options for remote work.
Full Job Description

Demonstrates deep subject matter expertise in environmental liability, with a strong focus on legacy policies, traditional environmental claims, and mass toxic tort exposures. Possesses a comprehensive understanding of historical policy language, long-tail liability trends, and complex allocation methodologies. Skilled in evaluating and managing high-severity, multi-party environmental losses, including contamination, pollution, and latent injury claims. Proven ability to navigate evolving legal and regulatory frameworks while partnering with internal and external stakeholders to drive effective claim resolution strategies. Brings thoughtful judgment, technical rigor, and strategic oversight to complex environmental portfolios within the Environmental Claim Unit (ECU).

#LI-KP1

#LI-Remote

Job Description Summary

The Excess Surplus (E&S) Claims team handles some of the most unique and interesting insurance claims at Nationwide. Many have complicated risks and loss history, requiring us to be adaptable and resilient in our work to help customers. If you love a challenge and can apply outstanding organizational, investigative and communication skills to your work, we want to hear from you!

As a Senior Claims Consultant, you'll investigate, evaluate and resolve complex claims of significant value. You'll provide direction to defense counsel handling lawsuits. We'll count on you to be a subject matter authority in a particular line of business or risk. In addition, you'll have opportunities to provide advice and counsel to E&S Claims leaders, insurance agents and internal business partners.

Job Description

Key Responsibilities: 

  • Handles, from inception to conclusion, the most serious and complex E&S claims. Settles or disposes of claims of significant value to the organization (e.g., risk exposure for individual policies in excess of $10 - 50 million; high limit excess, umbrella and unique risk with high limits – marine, aviation, director/officer, etc.).

  • Identifies and manages reserves in compliance with company standards and practices. Recommends special reserves as necessary.

  • Provides litigation strategies and consultation in partnership with defense counsel. Monitors litigation trends and practices to ensure that lawsuits are handled in a consistent fashion. Recommends changes to business leadership; provides implementation strategies and coordinates execution processes.

  • Builds and maintains relationships with agents, brokers and product developers. Helps develop business plans to ensure claims quality results.

  • Acts as Top level expert in product development and management for specialty lines of business. Provides standardized processes and claim handling expertise to new product development. 

  • Acts as top-level subject matter expert In specialty line claims. Identifies and develops training plans and strategies for the division. Provides niche training and consultation to non-claims areas.

  • Provides top level consultation/direction to E&S Claims leaders, peers and other business partners about severe specialty claims issues, coverages or risks. 

  • Maintains current knowledge of multiple coverage lines, venue-specific court decisions which may impact the claim function, current guidelines and policy changes and modifications.

  • May Manage associate performance, salary planning and administration, training and development, workflow and organizational planning, hiring and placement and disciplinary actions of contributing staff.

May perform other responsibilities as assigned.

Reporting Relationships: Reports to E&S Claims Director/Executive. May have up to three direct reports or serve as a project team leader. 

Typical Skills and Experiences: 


Education: Undergraduate education in insurance, business, management, or related fields. Advanced degree preferred.

Completion of insurance courses such as IIA, AEI, or CPCU preferred.

License/Certification/Designation: Associates must acquire the required Federal and/or state licenses/registrations within the time period designated by the business unit. Additional licenses/registrations may be required when new products and services are implemented. If an associate fails to acquire required licenses/registrations within the designated time period, the associate will be ineligible to continue in the position. 

Experience: Ten years prior insurance experience preferred. Demonstrated experience investigating and resolving complex coverage issues and litigated claims. Specific experience in a line of business preferred.

Knowledge, Abilities, and Skills: Deep knowledge of the best claims practices used to resolve the most severe claims. Demonstrated knowledge in a particular line of business and/or additional education may be required by the business unit (e.g., commercial/financial company, director and officer, ocean marine). High level of expertise relating to insurance contracts, coverage issues, contingent or extra-contractual liability against insurers and litigation management, both foreign and domestic. Sophisticated analytical skills to make independent decisions and resolve conflict in application of coverage to submitted claims, application of laws of jurisdiction to investigation facts, application of policy exclusions and exceptions. Confirmed ability to coordinate defense counsel handling cases involving serious and complex liability and damage issues from inception through trial. Exceptional oral and written communication skills when dealing with policyholders, claimants, attorneys, physicians and all levels of management. Organizational skills to effectively establish work priorities to meet objectives and standards. Demonstrated personal computer skills and the ability to operation claims and business software.

Other criteria, including leadership skills, competencies and experiences may take precedence.

Staffing exceptions to the above must be approved by the Vice President and HR Vice President.

Values: Regularly and consistently demonstrates the Nationwide Values.

Working Conditions:


Overtime Eligibility: Not Eligible (Exempt)

Working Conditions: Normal office environment. Travel as necessary.

We currently anticipate accepting applications until 09/17/2026. However, we encourage early submissions, as the posting may close sooner if a strong candidate slate is identified before the deadline.

Benefits

We have an array of benefits to fit your needs, including: medical/dental/vision,life insurance, short and long term disability coverage, paid time off with newly hired associates receiving a minimum of 18 days paid time off each full calendar year pro-rated quarterly based on hire date, nine paid holidays, 8 hours of Lifetime paid time off, 8 hours of Unity Day paid time off, 401(k) with company match, company-paid pension plan, business casual attire, and more. To learn more about the benefits we offer,click here.

This position could be filled within any of the lower 48 U.S. states.

#claims

About Nationwide Insurance

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company & Affiliated Companies is a group of large U.S. insurance and financial services companies based in Columbus, Ohio. Nationwide has grown from a small mutual auto insurer owned by policyholders to one of the largest insurance and financial services companies in the world, with more than $158 billion in statutory assets.

Nationwide Insurance Careers

Join the Nationwide Insurance team today and be part of a company that values innovation, leadership, and diversity. As one of the leading insurance and financial services providers, Nationwide offers unparalleled job opportunities that foster professional growth and development. Work You’ll Do At Nationwide Insurance, you’ll contribute to projects that impact lives and help communities thrive. You’ll work alongside a team of experts dedicated to upholding the highest standards in insurance and financial services. Our culture is built on a foundation of respect and integrity, driving us to achieve excellence in everything we do. Nationwide Insurance is not just about insurance; it’s about fostering an environment of continuous growth and innovation. With a variety of career paths available, from customer service to claims management, each position offers the chance to make a significant impact. Join Our Market-Leading Team Nationwide Insurance is home to some of the most dedicated professionals in the industry. Our team benefits from leadership that is committed to personal and professional development, ensuring that every employee has the opportunity for career advancement and skill enhancement. Innovate with Us Embrace the opportunity to work on groundbreaking projects that set industry standards. Nationwide’s commitment to innovation means constantly seeking out new ways to improve our services and processes, benefiting both our customers and our team members. Internship and Employment Opportunities Start your career with Nationwide Insurance through our internship programs or dive straight into a fulfilling career with vast employment opportunities. We are looking for passionate, curious, and driven individuals ready to make a difference in the insurance industry. Diversity and Inclusion At Nationwide, diversity and inclusion are more than just words—they are principles guiding how we build our teams, cultivate leaders, and create a company that’s the right fit for every person inside of it. We offer diversity training and resources that promote an inclusive workplace. Benefits and Culture Nationwide Insurance is committed to supporting our team members’ well-being both inside and outside of work. Our benefits package includes comprehensive health care, retirement plans, and generous paid time off. More than just benefits, our company culture encourages networking, mentorship, and community involvement. Career Development Invest in your future with Nationwide Insurance’s career development programs. From resume and interview workshops to advanced leadership training, we provide the tools to help you succeed and advance within the company. Stay Connected Join Our Team Explore the various positions available at Nationwide Insurance that match your skills and interests. We are continuously hiring and looking for new talent to join our professional network. Keep Up to Date Stay informed with career tips, insider perspectives, and industry-leading insights—all from the people who work at Nationwide Insurance. Job Alert Emails Customize your subscription to receive job alerts and the latest news tailored to your preferences. Discover the exciting and rewarding career opportunities that await at Nationwide Insurance. Join Nationwide Insurance today and be part of a team that is dedicated to making a difference in the lives of our customers and communities.
Learn more about Nationwide Insurance
Size
28,000 employees
Industry
Founded
1925

Similar Jobs

More Jobs at Nationwide Insurance

More Finance & Insurance Jobs

Find similar Senior Consultant, Claims Casualty - E&S/Specialty (Traditional Environmental Property Damage and Bodily Injury) jobs: