Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

Sales Operations Manager

Finance & Insurance
5 - 7 years of experience
Job Overview by Ladders

Qualifications

  • Bachelor's degree in Business, Marketing, Finance, Data Analytics, or related field.
  • 5+ years in Property & Casualty insurance, sales operations, or distribution management.
  • Experience managing CRM platforms like Salesforce or Microsoft Dynamics.
  • Proven leadership experience with administrative or operational teams.
  • Strong analytical skills with proficiency in reporting and dashboards.
  • Advanced Excel skills; familiarity with Power BI or Tableau is a plus.
  • Strong understanding of insurance distribution models and sales metrics.

Responsibilities

  • Lead sales performance reporting with insights into trends and profitability.
  • Develop executive dashboards to support data-driven decisions.
  • Ensure data integrity across sales reporting tools.
  • Monitor the sales budget, tracking variances and forecasting outcomes.
  • Serve as business owner of the CRM platform, guiding user adoption.
  • Manage agency data, ensuring accuracy and compliance in documentation.
  • Conduct competitive market research on agency support and compensation.

Benefits

  • Hybrid work setup with flexibility based on business needs.
  • High visibility and influence with Sales Leadership.
  • Opportunity to shape data strategy and agency compensation models.
  • Leadership role with the chance to develop a small team.
  • Engagement in ongoing professional development and continuous improvement initiatives.
Full Job Description
Drive the systems, insights, and operations behind profitable sales growth.

Hastings Insurance is seeking a Sales Operations Manager to support and strengthen our Property & Casualty sales organization. This role leads the operational and analytical infrastructure behind our distribution strategy, providing the reporting, tools, and processes that enable informed decision-making and sustained growth. You will partner closely with Sales Leadership, Finance, IT, and agency partners to ensure our sales operations are efficient, data-driven, and positioned for the future.
Schedule & Location

This is a full-time position working Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. The role is hybrid, requiring regular in-office presence at our Hastings, Michigan headquarters, with flexibility based on business needs. Occasional work outside of standard hours may be required.
What You'll Do:
  • Lead sales performance reporting, including weekly, monthly, quarterly, and annual production summaries, with clear insights into trends, pipeline activity, retention, hit ratios, and profitability.
  • Develop and deliver executive-level dashboards and reporting packages to support data-driven decision-making.
  • Ensure consistency in metric definitions and maintain strong data integrity across all sales reporting tools and systems.
  • Monitor and analyze the sales department budget, including tracking variances and forecasting outcomes in partnership with Finance.
  • Provide leadership with variance explanations and actionable recommendations to support business performance.
  • Serve as the primary business owner of the CRM platform, overseeing configuration, optimization, workflow development, and user adoption.
  • Lead agency data management efforts, including data entry oversight, cleansing, normalization, and long-term data strategy development.
  • Prepare sales and agency data for future analytics, automation, and predictive modeling initiatives.
  • Supervise and develop administrative team members, providing coaching, direction, and performance management.
  • Oversee day-to-day operational workflows including agency data updates, documentation, and contract processing.
  • Promote a culture of accuracy, efficiency, and continuous improvement within the team.
  • Draft, manage, and maintain agency contracts, including licensing records, appointments, compensation structures, and agreements.
  • Serve as the primary contact for contract-related inquiries and ensure compliance with corporate and regulatory standards.
  • Maintain accurate and complete documentation of all agency relationships and contractual obligations.
  • Conduct competitive market research on commissions, incentives, and agency support models to evaluate positioning.
  • Identify market trends impacting agent relationships, retention, and sales performance.
  • Provide strategic recommendations to leadership based on research findings and internal data insights.
  • Plan and coordinate sales events, agency meetings, and advisory councils, including logistics, materials, communications, and execution.
  • Partner with internal stakeholders and vendors to ensure successful event delivery and follow-up.
  • Collaborate with Training, IT, Data, and Sales Leadership to align systems, reporting, and development initiatives.
  • Support training coordination to ensure materials and programs remain relevant and effective.
  • Participate in ongoing professional development and support continuous improvement initiatives across sales operations.
Additional Role Highlights:
  • Lead and develop a small team of administrative professionals supporting sales operations.
  • Play a central role in shaping data strategy and future analytics capabilities.
  • High visibility with Sales Leadership and cross-functional partners.
  • Opportunity to influence agency strategy, compensation models, and operational efficiency.
  • Blend of analytical, operational, and leadership responsibilities.
What You'll Bring:
  • Bachelor's degree in Business, Marketing, Finance, Data Analytics, or a related field.
  • Five or more years of experience in Property & Casualty insurance, sales operations, or distribution management.
  • Experience managing CRM platforms such as Salesforce, Microsoft Dynamics, or similar systems.
  • Demonstrated experience leading or supervising administrative or operational teams.
  • Experience managing contracts, compensation structures, or agency relationships.
  • Strong analytical skills with experience in reporting, dashboards, and performance metrics.
  • Advanced Excel skills; experience with Power BI, Tableau, or similar tools preferred.
  • Strong understanding of insurance distribution models and sales performance metrics.
  • Excellent communication skills with the ability to work across teams and with leadership.
  • Strong organizational and project management skills with attention to detail.
  • Ability to translate data into actionable insights and recommendations.
  • Adaptability and the ability to manage changing priorities and business needs.

About Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company is a regional insurance company that provides property and casualty insurance products to individuals and businesses in the Midwest. The company was founded in 1885 and is headquartered in Hastings, Michigan. Hastings Mutual Insurance Company offers a range of insurance products, including auto, home, and business insurance. The company is committed to providing excellent customer service and has received numerous awards for its customer satisfaction.
Learn more about Hastings Mutual Insurance Company
Size
600 employees
Industry
Founded
1885

Similar Jobs

More Jobs at Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

  • Hastings Mutual Insurance Company
    Integration Developer
    $70K — $95K *
    Hastings, MI 49058 (Barry County)
    Finance & Insurance
    Hybrid
  • Hastings Mutual Insurance Company
    Associate Actuary
    $70K — $95K *
    Hastings, MI 49058 (Barry County)
    Finance & Insurance
    Hybrid

More Finance & Insurance Jobs

Find similar Sales Operations Manager jobs: